Blockk Blockk Blockk Blockk
  • News Portal
  • World Desk
    • Sign In
    • Submit Content
    • Register
  • All Content
    • Edited
      • Topics
        • Agriculture
        • Culture
          • Arts
          • Children
          • Education
          • Entertainment
          • Food and Hunger
          • Sports
        • Disasters
        • Economy
        • Energy
        • Environment
        • Government
        • Health
        • Media
        • Science
        • Spiritual
        • Technology
        • Transportation
        • War
      • Regions
        • Africa
        • Americas
          • North America
          • South America
        • Antarctica
        • Arctic
        • Asia
        • Australia/Oceania
        • Europe
        • Middle East
        • Oceans
          • Arctic Ocean
          • Atlantic Ocean
          • Indian Ocean
          • Pacific Ocean
          • Southern Ocean
        • Space
      • News
      • Commentary
      • Analysis
      • Advisories
      • Source
    • Flatwire
  • About Us
  • Site Map
  • Contact Us

Latest Stories

... loading images
Our Digital Twins Will Help Diagnose And Treat Diseases ...
Our Digital Twins Will Help Diagnose And Treat Diseases | Thomas Gull, University of Zurich
US Farmers, Tech Tycoons Square Off Over Plans For Utopian ...
US Farmers, Tech Tycoons Square Off Over Plans For Utopian City | Glenn Chapman
Falling Solar Power And Storage Prices Make Global Climate ...
Falling Solar Power And Storage Prices Make Global Climate Transition Cheaper Than Expected | Ulrich von Lampe
Why the Next Crypto Bull Run Will Be Like Nothing We've ...
Why the Next Crypto Bull Run Will Be Like Nothing We've Ever Experienced | Solo Ceesay
Human-Driven Mass Extinction Is Eliminating Entire Branches ...
Human-Driven Mass Extinction Is Eliminating Entire Branches Of The Tree Of Life | Stanford University
The Untold Story of the Abuse of Palestinian Women in ...
The Untold Story of the Abuse of Palestinian Women in Hebron | Ramzy Baroud
‘Bread and Circuses’: Musk, Zuckerberg and the Art of ...
‘Bread and Circuses’: Musk, Zuckerberg and the Art of Distraction | Ramzy Baroud
What Are Smart Contracts? | Bing
What Are Smart Contracts? | Bing
Climate Conflagration: Maui to Montana | Amy Goodman & ...
Climate Conflagration: Maui to Montana | Amy Goodman & Denis Moynihan
Best Way To Enter News Stories Into A Blockchain? | Bing
Best Way To Enter News Stories Into A Blockchain? | Bing
War By Other Means: Short-Selling JPMorgan | Ellen Brown
War By Other Means: Short-Selling JPMorgan | Ellen Brown
Israel’s Slippery Slope | Nouriel Roubini
Israel’s Slippery Slope | Nouriel Roubini
How To Stop And Reverse Global Warming | Bing
How To Stop And Reverse Global Warming | Bing
US and Israel: Is the ‘Unbreakable Bond’ Finally Breaking? ...
US and Israel: Is the ‘Unbreakable Bond’ Finally Breaking? | Ramzy Baroud
Meaning Of Solidarity In The Time Of A New Palestine | ...
Meaning Of Solidarity In The Time Of A New Palestine | Ramzy Baroud
CLASS WAR: America’s Privileged Technocrats Not Ready For ...
CLASS WAR: America’s Privileged Technocrats Not Ready For What’s About To Happen To Them | Jon Schwarz

Belgium is on the Right Track, but Europe has Failed Palestine | Ramzy Baroud

More items by author
Categories
Edited | Front Page Stories | All Content | Economy | Business | Government | Politics | Technology | North America | Europe | Middle East | Commentary | Commentary -- WNT Reports
Tool Bar
View Comments

EU Representative Sven Kühn von Burgsdorff visits Palestinian communities threatened by settlement expansion around East Jerusalem. (Photo: via EUD Palestine)EU Representative Sven Kühn von Burgsdorff visits Palestinian communities threatened by settlement expansion around East Jerusalem. (Photo: via EUD Palestine)

 

Ramzy Baroud -- World News Trust

Dec. 1, 2021

The Belgian government’s decision on Nov. 25 to label products made in illegal Israeli Jewish settlements is welcome, although it will ultimately prove ineffectual.

Belgium has historically shown solidarity with Palestine compared with other European countries, for example, Britain, Germany and France. From the cancellation of trade missions to Israel to the effusive support by Belgian civil society, artists, scholars and ordinary people, Belgium has demonstrated the desire to play a constructive role in ending the Israeli occupation of Palestine.

Obviously, it will take more than symbolic solidarity and political statements to force Israel to respect international law, to dismantle apartheid, end the military occupation and grant Palestinians their freedom.

Belgium’s dilemma is the same across Europe. Whereas European governments insist on the centrality of the questions of democracy, human rights and international law in their dealings with Israel, they fail to carry out any meaningful steps to ensure Israel complies with declared European Union policies.

Belgium’s decision to differentiate between Israeli products made in Israel and those made in illegal Jewish settlements is not predicated on Brussels’ own legal frame of reference, but on several EU landmark decisions in this regard. For example, in November 2015, the EU issued new guidelines to ensure illegal settlement products are being labelled as such. In January 2016, the EU had reportedly "reinforced"its position that such products must be clearly labeled.

However, little labeling has taken place since, a reality that compelled EU citizens, with the support of various civil society organisations, to challenge the failure of the European political establishment by appealing directly to EU courts. In November 2019, the EU’s top court, the European Court of Justice, ruled that products from illegal Israeli settlements must provide an “indication of that provenance (allowing consumers to make) informed choices.”

Namely, Belgium’s recent decision is but a belated implementation of various rulings that have been made in the past and were left unfulfilled by most EU countries.

Instead of showing complete support of Belgium and initiating their own process of implementing the EU Court’s ruling, most European countries remained silent as Tel Aviv raged against Brussels, claiming that the decision is “anti-Israeli,” alleging, inaccurately that it “strengthens extremists.”

As soon as the Belgian government’s decision was reported in international media, Israel threw its usual tantrum. Deputy Foreign Minister, Idan Roll, immediately cancelled a scheduled meeting he had with Belgian officials, compelling the Foreign Ministry’s office in Brussels to justify and further clarify its position.

Expectedly, the Palestinian Authority, Palestinian rights groups, civil society organisations and many individuals commended Belgium on its courageous position, which is akin to other such positions adopted in the past by countries like Ireland which, in May, became the first EU country to execute such a measure.

The prevailing wisdom behind such euphoria is that such steps can serve as a prelude to other practical steps, which could ultimately generate the needed momentum for a full European boycott of Israel. But is this, indeed, the case?

Judging by the European division on labelling products made in illegal settlements, the clear distinction between settlements and "Israel proper," and the exponentially growing trade between Israel and the EU, one must be cautious not to jump to premature conclusions.

According to European Commission figures, the EU is Israel’s biggest trade partner, with a total trade value of €31 billion in 2020.

More important than trade is that the EU has been the main access point in integrating Israel into a larger global dynamics of politics, economy, security and even culture, music and sports. While European trade with Israel is facilitated through the EU-Israel Association Agreement of 1995, integrating Israel into Europe is managed largely through the European Neighbourhood Policy Action Plan (ENP) of 2004. The latter agreement, in particular, was aimed at offsetting the delegitimisation of the Israeli occupation and apartheid in Palestine achieved by Palestinians and their supporters.

It would be implausible to believe that the EU, which has made a strategic choice to legitimise, integrate and normalise Israel in the eyes of Europeans and the rest of the international community, can also be the very entity that holds Israel accountable to its obligations under international law.

It must also be remembered that, even if all European countries decide to label settlement products, that alone will not deter Israel, especially since the EU will do its utmost to make up whatever trade deficit resulting from that move.

Moreover, any symbolic or even real pressure applied by the EU is often carried out within the framework of the European stated desire for a two-state solution in Israel and Palestine. While it is true that such a "solution" remains the only one ratified by the international community, the complexity of the problem, common sense and "facts on the ground" tell us that coexistence in one democratic secular state remains the only practical, possible and nominally just end to this protracted tragedy.

Despite the articulate and even unambiguous statements by the EU regarding the illegality of the Israeli occupation, it is obvious that the Europeans do not have an actual strategy on Palestine and Israel. If such a strategy exists, it is riddled with confusion and contradictions. In truth, Israel has no reason to take Europe seriously.

It is easy to accuse the EU of hypocrisy. However, there is more to the EU’s conduct in Israel than hypocrisy, arguably resulting from the lack of political unity and a shared vision among EU members.

The EU is, in fact, helping sustain the Israeli occupation, financing it either directly or indirectly. EU trade, political validation and cultural integration of Israel have allowed the status quo of the seemingly endless occupation of Palestine to continue. No amount of labelling of products from Jewish settlements will, on its own, reverse this.

While Belgium’s position, on its own, is praiseworthy -- as it reflects the ceaseless activism and pressure of the country’s own civil society -- it should not be seen as an alternative to a courageous political and moral position, similar to the one taken during the anti-apartheid struggle in South Africa. Until then, Europe is obligated to demonstrate its willingness to stand on the right side of history.

Dr. Ramzy BaroudDr. Ramzy BaroudRamzy Baroud is a journalist and the Editor of The Palestine Chronicle. He is the author of five books. His latest is “These Chains Will Be Broken: Palestinian Stories of Struggle and Defiance in Israeli Prisons” (Clarity Press). Dr. Baroud is a Non-resident Senior Research Fellow at the Center for Islam and Global Affairs (CIGA). His website is www.ramzybaroud.net 

back to top
  • Created
    Wednesday, December 01, 2021
  • Last modified
    Saturday, February 05, 2022

World Desk Activities

  • Report
Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin ▶ Editorial -- Blockchain & Crypto 21/09/2023
  • Report
 

www.entrepreneur.com/money-finance/3-reasons-why-t…

3 Reasons Why the Next Crypto Bull Run Will Be Like Nothing We've Ever Experienced | Entrepreneur
3 Reasons Why the Next Crypto Bull Run Will Be Like Nothing We've Ever Experienced | Entrepreneur We are on the precipice of what could be the greatest transfer of wealth that has ever happened in human history. www.entrepreneur.com/money-finance/3-reasons-why-the-next-crypto-bull-run-will-be-like-nothing/458852
  • Report
Francis M Goodwin
BIG WAVE SURFING COMPILATION 2020 is now a featured video. 14/09/2023
BIG WAVE SURFING COMPILATION 2020

BIG WAVE SURFING COMPILATION 2020

** BIG WAVE SURFING COMPILATION 2020 ** 60-100FT** WORLD RECORD MONSTER WAVES - AMAZING FOOTAGE **Please Subscribe if You Would like to see More...

  • Report
Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin ▶ World News Trust Project 14/09/2023
  • Report
 

www.niemanlab.org/2023/09/the-colorado-sun-a-pione…

The Colorado Sun, a pioneering for-profit/nonprofit hybrid, moves toward a fully nonprofit model | Nieman Journalism Lab
The Colorado Sun, a pioneering for-profit/nonprofit hybrid, moves toward a fully nonprofit model | Nieman Journalism Lab "Whether I agree with it or not, whether I even like it or not, the reality is that many individuals, many institutions and philanthropic groups,… www.niemanlab.org/2023/09/the-colorado-sun-a-pioneering-for-profit-nonprofit-hybrid-moves-toward-a-fully-nonprofit-model/
  • Report
Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin ▶ Editorial -- Blockchain & Crypto 14/09/2023
  • Report
 

www.coindesk.com/consensus-magazine/2023/09/13/3-b…

3 Big Drivers Determining the Future of Crypto in the U.S.
3 Big Drivers Determining the Future of Crypto in the U.S. Blockchain Association CEO Kristin Smith weighs where the digital asset industry may be in the next half decade, on the organization's five-year anniversary. www.coindesk.com/consensus-magazine/2023/09/13/3-big-drivers-determining-the-future-of-crypto-in-the-us/
  • Report
Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin ▶ Editorial -- Blockchain & Crypto 14/09/2023
  • Report
 

www.coindesk.com/consensus-magazine/2023/09/13/wha…

What Will Be the Next Target of the SEC's Enforcement Regime?
What Will Be the Next Target of the SEC's Enforcement Regime? Troutman Pepper lawyers predict that crypto wallets and TradFi firms could face the agency's wrath. www.coindesk.com/consensus-magazine/2023/09/13/what-will-be-the-next-target-of-the-secs-enforcement-regime/
  • Report
Francis M Goodwin
Does Buddhism support romantic love? is now a featured video. 11/09/2023
Does Buddhism support romantic love?

Does Buddhism support romantic love?

Thich Nhat Hanh answers questions during a retreat in Plum Village (May, 2014).Question: If Buddhism supports love for Mother Nature why doesn't it...

  • Report
Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin ▶ Editorial 11/09/2023
  • Report
 

americanpressinstitute.org/publications/articles/b…

Building source tracking into newsroom workflows - American Press Institute
Building source tracking into newsroom workflows - American Press Institute americanpressinstitute.org/publications/articles/building-source-tracking-into-newsroom-workflows/
  • Report
Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin ▶ Editorial 11/09/2023
  • Report
 

reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/digital-news-re…

News podcasts: who is listening and what formats are working? | Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism
News podcasts: who is listening and what formats are working? | Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism Over the last few years, much has been written about a so-called golden age of podcasting, which many date from the launch of the true… reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/digital-news-report/2023/news-podcasts-who-is-listening-what-formats-are-working
  • Report
Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin ▶ Editorial 11/09/2023
  • Report
 

ijnet.org/en/story/tips-conduct-investigations-tv-…

Tips to conduct investigations for TV, from ICFJ Knight Award winner Riad Kobaissi | International Journalists' Network
Tips to conduct investigations for TV, from ICFJ Knight Award winner Riad Kobaissi | International Journalists' Network The 2020 Beirut port blast – one of the largest non-nuclear explosions in history – killed more than 200 people and injured over 6,500. It… ijnet.org/en/story/tips-conduct-investigations-tv-icfj-knight-award-winner-riad-kobaissi
  • Report
Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin ▶ Editorial 11/09/2023
  • Report
 

ijnet.org/en/story/digital-training-tool-helps-loc…

This digital training tool helps local community members become journalists | International Journalists' Network
This digital training tool helps local community members become journalists | International Journalists' Network In early 2020, Lindsey and Joey Young, owners of the small rural media company, Kansas Publishing Ventures (KPV), were interviewing a journalism school graduate for… ijnet.org/en/story/digital-training-tool-helps-local-community-members-become-journalists
blue-flag-thumb2_50x50Our side's flag is a thin, airlight blue, drifting almost unseen against the sky. Our military march is a meadowlark's song among the dandelions.
--Ken Kesey, The Real War 
 
Welcome to the World News Trust social news network. We are dedicated to your privacy and the highest standards of journalistic excellence. Help us build a great news service. Visit our World Desk community to register or log in. See you there.
 
 -Francis Goodwin, World News Trust founder

Community Videos

  • David Bowie - Under Pressure (Live) 1996 • TopPop 04:07
  • Chumbawamba - Tubthumping 03:34
  • ZZ Top - La Grange (Live From Gruene Hall) | Stages 04:38
  • Exmagma - Goldball   1974  (full album) 35:06
  • Digital News Report 2023 | Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism 02:20
  • Let 'Em Sing 04:31
View all videos

Popular

  • CLASS WAR: America’s Privileged Technocrats Not Ready For What’s About To Happen To Them | Jon Schwarz
  • How To Stop And Reverse Global Warming | Bing
  • Meaning Of Solidarity In The Time Of A New Palestine | Ramzy Baroud
  • The Federal Debt Trap: Issues and Possible Solutions | Ellen Brown
  • US and Israel: Is the ‘Unbreakable Bond’ Finally Breaking? | Ramzy Baroud

Blogs & Submissions

  • Israeli ‘Coup’ and the Death of False Democracy | Ramzy Baroud
  • The Other Side of the West Africa Upheaval | Ramzy Baroud
  • ‘Bread and Circuses’: Musk, Zuckerberg and the Art of Distraction | Ramzy Baroud
  • The Twisted Israeli Logic of Murdering Palestinian Children, and What Can We Do to Stop It? | Ramzy ...
  • Can BRICS, Global South Help Us Escape the West’s Hegemony, Contradictions? | Ramzy Baroud and Roman...
The Federal Debt Trap: Issues and Possible Solutions | ...
The Federal Debt Trap: Issues and Possible Solutions | Ellen Brown
Prophets of Doom: Kissinger and the ‘Intellectual’ Decline ...
Prophets of Doom: Kissinger and the ‘Intellectual’ Decline of the West | Ramzy Baroud
Why US Democrats Are Growingly Challenging Israel | Ramzy ...
Why US Democrats Are Growingly Challenging Israel | Ramzy Baroud
The Financial Transactions Tax That Could Eliminate Need ...
The Financial Transactions Tax That Could Eliminate Need for All Others | Ellen Brown
How Palestinians Defeated Netanyahu and Redefined ‘Unity’ | ...
How Palestinians Defeated Netanyahu and Redefined ‘Unity’ | Ramzy Baroud
Transphobia | Wikipedia
Transphobia | Wikipedia
Did Entheogens Cause Human Intelligence? | Bard
Did Entheogens Cause Human Intelligence? | Bard
How To Deinstitutionalize The Practice Of Human Warfare | ...
How To Deinstitutionalize The Practice Of Human Warfare | Bard

Electronic Frontier Foundation

  • Don’t Fall for the Intelligence Community’s Monster of the Week Justifications
    September 22, 2023
  • This Bill Would Revive The Worst Patents On Software—And Human Genes  
    September 21, 2023
  • Today The UK Parliament Undermined The Privacy, Security, And Freedom Of All Internet Users 
    September 19, 2023
  • We Want YOU (U.S. Federal Employees) to Stand for Digital Freedoms
    September 19, 2023

The Intercept

  • FBI Warned Sikhs in the U.S. About Death Threats After Killing of Canadian Activist
    September 23, 2023
  • The Secret History of How the Super-Rich Have Kept the Working Class Out of Work
    September 23, 2023
  • Menendez "Appreciated" Meeting With Egypt Dictator Amid Alleged Bribes for Arms Sales
    September 22, 2023
  • North Carolina GOP Hides Redistricting Process From State Public Records Law
    September 22, 2023

VTDigger

  • Morrill Homestead reopens following summer flood damage
    September 24, 2023
  • Town of 5 people stakes claim on federal dollars that previously went to Bennington County
    September 24, 2023
  • Vermont expects a huge pot of federal money to provide broadband, but with strings attached
    September 24, 2023
  • Bob Stannard: Are the kids ready to move into the spotlight? 
    September 24, 2023

Mountain Times -- Central Vermont

  • September 22, 2023
  • Mountain Times – Volume 51, Number 38 – Sept. 20-26, 2023
    September 21, 2023
  • Are you ready for the Rollins? He’s ready for you!
    September 20, 2023
  • ‘Baby it’s not so cold outside’
    September 20, 2023
  1. You are here:  
  2. Home
  3. All Content
  4. Edited
  5. Belgium is on the Right Track, but Europe has Failed Palestine | Ramzy Baroud
Copyright © 2023 World News Trust. All Rights Reserved.
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU General Public License.